What's the difference here?

These are two efforts I did to set my signature. They’re really similar, and when you swap the resulting signature numbers, they just about fit both efforts.

For some reason, the 2022 effort was interpreted as me having a higher relative TP, and the 2023 was interpreted as a much higher HIE, and lower TP. @ManofSteele , and anyone else who wants to chime in, what’s going on here? Which one is “right”?